At times the most terrifying monsters aren’t the ones lurking in the shadows, but the people who refuse to accept anyone different from themselves. Hildur Knútsdóttir delivers a story with strong ties to this statement in Down Where Monsters Dwell, a truly haunting and unsettling novella that packs a punch in a small package.
Centuries ago, in the isolated fjords of Iceland, a woman named Halla rescues a baby girl, abandoned by her parents who fear she’s a changeling. Halla doesn’t believe in such nonsense and decides to take her home.
And she’s right – the child, Æsa, is not a changeling. But she’s not exactly human either. As she grows up, terrifying rumors of a violent woman with a monster’s face begin to spread through the fjord’s other farmsteads.
Human or not, Halla knows her daughter isn’t a monster. She must do whatever she can to protect Æsa because she knows: scared people can do terrible things.
First off, Knútsdóttir is quickly becoming one of the greats in the realm of novella horror stories. The 150-175 pages given in a typical novella is the perfect length for Hildur to really get her point across, terrifying us, truly create something haunting, and in most cases very poignant. This also goes for Down Where Monsters Dwell, a story of Mother-Daughter relationship that goes beyond that with only a few words to tell the story.
Mothers (and in my case fathers) will go to great lengths to protect their children, even those who they did not give birth to, but raised, cared, and nurtured along the way. There is a bond that is not quantifiable between a mother and daughter, one that pushes the mother to great lengths to care for their child. Down Where Monsters Dwell with just this in mind. Not to mention how people, mostly men, treat women or those who the great world considers different.
Yes, the relationship between Halla, Æsa, and even her sister is the story here, but I also saw that people who see someone outside the traditional norm and treat them any different are truly awful. Æsa is a living soul, she deserves to be treated with respect, love, and to be cared for, but her birth parents wanted nothing to do with her, and as she grew older was treated differently because people didn’t understand or care. It’s a reflection of the world we live in, one where people care more about what the traditional life looks like and not for the soul within.
This is a horror story for sure, but Down Where Monsters Dwell is more of an atmospheric and unsettling unease style of horror where the tension is built throughout and deals with some poignant matters that are horrifying in their own right. As I said before, it’s the most wonderful length and gets the point across quickly, immersing us in a gothic haunting of a story where the pages almost turned themselves.
Down Where Monsters Dwell is a beautifully haunting tale of a mother’s unconditional love and the fear of those who are different, those who go to terrifying lengths when they don’t understand. Hildur Knútsdóttir delivers a chilling and heartbreaking gothic horror novella that sometimes the most frightening monsters are often the ones who look just like us.
Down Where Monsters Dwell hits bookstores everywhere on March 9, 2027 from Tor Nightfire. The audiobook, narrated by Mary Robinette Kowal, is available via Libro.fm!


