By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Capes and Tights
  • Comics

    COMICS

    • Comic News
    • Comic Reviews
    • Comic Previews

    FEATURED PUBLISHERS

    • Marvel Comics
    • DC Comics
    • Image Comics
    • IDW Publishing
    • Dark Horse Comics
    • BOOM! Studios
    • Mad Cave Studios

    THE LATEST IN COMICS

    FEATURED 4: DC's Naughty List #1, Robin Hood #1, and November 25 Comics
    FEATURED 4: DC’s Naughty List #1, Robin Hood #1, and November 25 Comics
    Leaded Gasoline #1
    Leaded Gasoline #1: A Chilling Look at the Lives Society Overlooks
    Uncle Scrooge: A Christmas Carol #1
    Uncle Scrooge: A Christmas Carol #1 – A Heartwarming Holiday Adventure
    14 Fabulous Comics by Declan Shalvey You Should Read
    14 Fabulous Comics by Declan Shalvey You Should Read

    LATEST COMIC PODCAST

    Declan Shalvey

    #308: Declan Shalvey – A Quiet Place: Rising Tides, ThunderCats, Old Dog, Moon Knight

  • Books

    BOOKS

    • Book News
    • Book Reviews
    • Stephen King

    FEATURED PUBLISHERS

    • Shortwave Publishing
    • Tor Nightfire
    • Saga Press
    • CLASH Books
    • Flatiron Books
    • Blackstone Publishing
    • Poisoned Pen Press

    THE LATEST IN BOOKS

    Mr. Lonelyhearts
    Mr. Lonelyhearts: Controlled Chaos of Emotion and Horror
    Down Where Monsters Dwell
    Down Where Monsters Dwell: A Chilling and Heartbreaking Tale of Unconditional Love
    The One We Buried
    The One We Buried: Some Secrets Are Too Dark to Stay Buried
    The Secret Lives of Zombie Wives
    The Secret Lives of Zombie Wives: A Delightfully Twisted Take on the Undead

    LATEST BOOKS PODCAST

    Alice Openshaw

    #307: Alice Openshaw – On The Killer’s Trail

  • TV

    TV

    • TV News
    • TV Reviews
    • TV Previews
    • TV Trailers

    THE LATEST IN TV

    The Dunder Mifflin Employee Manual
    The Dunder Mifflin Employee Manual: An Ingenious New Way to Revisit The Office
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    I Am the Night
    I Am the Night: Shining the Bat-Signal on an Animated Classic

    LATEST TV PODCAST

    The Lawrence Brothers

    #302: The Lawrence Brothers – The Lawrence Brothers: Detective Agency

  • Movies

    MOVIES

    • Movie News
    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie Previews
    • Movie Trailers
    • Marvel Cinematic Universe
    • MCU Watch Order

    THE LATEST IN MOVIES

    Blumhouse Brings Blockbuster Film Franchises To IDW Publishing's Hit Horror Imprint IDW Dark
    Blumhouse Brings Blockbuster Film Franchises To IDW Publishing’s Hit Horror Imprint IDW Dark
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    16 Magical Movies by Kevin Smith You Should Watch
    16 Magical Movies by Kevin Smith You Should Watch

    LATEST MOVIES PODCAST

    Casper

    #305: Casper Movie Review

  • The Podcast

    THE PODCAST

    • Episodes
    • Podcast Schedule
    • Submit to Be a Guest

    SUBSCRIBE

    • Apple
    • Spotify
    • YouTube
    • Amazon
    • Pocket Casts

    RECENT EPISODES

    Declan Shalvey
    #308: Declan Shalvey – A Quiet Place: Rising Tides, ThunderCats, Old Dog, Moon Knight
    Alice Openshaw
    #307: Alice Openshaw – On The Killer’s Trail
    Jonathan Edward Durham
    #306: Jonathan Edward Durham – Winterset Hollow
    Casper
    #305: Casper Movie Review

    UPCOMING EPISODES

    Declan Shalvey
    November 18, 2026
    The Nightmare Before Christmas
    December 2, 2026
    Chris Ryall
    November 25, 2026
    Joe Harris
    December 9, 2026
  • Publishers

    COMIC PUBLISHERS

    BOOK PUBLISHERS

    Marvel Comics
    BOOM Studios
    Dynamite
    Image Comics
    DC Comics
    Dark Horse
    IDW
    Mad Cave
    AWA Studios
    DSTLRY
    Ignition Press
    Oni Press
    Blackstone Publishing
    Flatiron Books
    Saga Press
    Clash Books
    Poisoned Pen Press
    Shortwave Publishing
    Crooked Lane Books
  • Franchises

    Franchises

    Marvel Comics
    Goosebumps
    DC Comics
    Ghostbusters
    Star Wars
    Spawn
    Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles | TMNT
    Star Trek
    The Walking Dead
    Horror
Reading: When We Were Silent: A Thought-Provoking Thriller
Share
Capes and Tights
  • Comics
  • Books
  • Movies
  • TV
  • The Podcast

THE PODCAST

  • Episodes
  • Podcast Schedule
  • Submit to Be a Guest
  • Subscribe on Apple
  • Follow on Spotify
  • Subscribe on YouTube

COMICS

  • Comic News
  • Comic Reviews
  • Comic Previews

TV

  • TV News
  • TV Reviews
  • TV Previews
  • TV Trailers

MOVIES

  • Movie News
  • Movie Reviews
  • Movie Previews
  • Movie Trailers

BOOKS

  • Book News
  • Book Reviews
Books

When We Were Silent: A Thought-Provoking Thriller

By
Justin Soderberg
Published: May 16, 2024
1.7K Views
Share
2 Min Read
When We Were Silent
SHARE
When We Were Silent
2.5
Review Overview

In When We Were Silent, Fiona McPhillips takes on a journey of privilege, exploitation, and retribution. While the subject matter is important, we felt the story fell a little flat for us.

The story follows Louise Manson, a new student at Highfield Manor, who befriends the wealthy Shauna Power. As Lou gets further into her school year, she is exposed to the school’s dark secrets.

McPhillips uses a dual timeline structure, using both past and present timelines, to add depth to the narrative. This allows the reader to explore the past events to see how their repercussions are felt in present day. However, we found ourselves only wanting to stay in the dark atmosphere of the past timeline but were forced into the present.

While the book initially had us hooked with its dark academia vibes and compelling premise, we lost interest as the story progressed. The pacing was slow at times, and certain plot points felt predictable. Additionally, the ending left us underwhelmed. Despite these drawbacks, When We Were Silent raises important themes of exploitation and privilege that could potentially spark meaningful conversations in the future.

When We Were Silent is thought-provoking and sheds light on some important social issues, but overall we felt like the story was just not for us. For those looking for a store with a tough subject matter this might be worth grabbing and taking a chance on this novel.

When We Were Silent hits bookstores everywhere on May 21, 2024. Check out the audiobook narrated by India Mullen on Libro.fm!

NOTE: We received an advance reading copy of When We Were Silent from the publisher. Opinions are our own.

When We Were Silent
Review Overview
2.5
Overall 2.5 out of 5
- Advertisement -
Share This Article
Facebook Threads Email Copy Link Print
ByJustin Soderberg
Follow:
Born and raised in New England, Justin Soderberg currently resides in Orrington, Maine. Soderberg started his career in media covering the UMass Lowell River Hawks, Lowell Spinners, Hockey East, PGA, Boston Bruins, MMA/UFC, and other sports. Now, Soderberg's main goal is to bring you the best possible pop culture coverage with all his effort.
Previous Article Galaxy of Madness #1 Galaxy of Madness #1: A Visually Wonderful Journey Through Space
Next Article 2024 Eisner Nominees Announced 2024 Eisner Nominees Announced

LATEST IN BOOKS

Mr. Lonelyhearts

Mr. Lonelyhearts: Controlled Chaos of Emotion and Horror

Justin Soderberg
November 18, 2026
Down Where Monsters Dwell

Down Where Monsters Dwell: A Chilling and Heartbreaking Tale of Unconditional Love

Justin Soderberg
November 16, 2026
The One We Buried

The One We Buried: Some Secrets Are Too Dark to Stay Buried

Justin Soderberg
November 16, 2026
- Advertisement -

LATEST BOOK PODCAST

Alice Openshaw

#307: Alice Openshaw – On The Killer’s Trail

- Advertisement -

BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE

Do You See What I See?
Books

Do You See What I See?: The Wonderful Setup for Murder

The Spare
Books

The Spare: Feeling Like the Odd One Out Has Never Been So Terrifying

FEATURED 4: Satanic Panic #1, I Saw Santa Vol. 1 TP, and October 28 Comics
Comics

FEATURED 4: Satanic Panic #1, I Saw Santa Vol. 1 TP, and October 28 Comics

Mr. Lonelyhearts
Books

Mr. Lonelyhearts: Controlled Chaos of Emotion and Horror

Depth Charge
Books

Depth Charge: A Brutal Reminder That Every Moment Matters

Down Where Monsters Dwell
Books

Down Where Monsters Dwell: A Chilling and Heartbreaking Tale of Unconditional Love

Capes and Tights

COMICS

  • Comic News
  • Comic Reviews
  • Comic Previews
  • Marvel Comics
  • DC Comics
  • Image Comics
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • IDW Publishing
  • BOOM! Studios
  • Mad Cave Studios
  • Ignition Press

BOOKS

  • Book News
  • Book Reviews
  • Anna Rose Reads
  • Shortwave Publishing
  • Tor Nightfire
  • Saga Press
  • CLASH Books
  • Flatiron Books
  • Blackstone Publishing
  • Poisoned Pen Press
  • Stephen King

Movies

  • Movie News
  • Movie Reviews
  • Movie Previews
  • Movie Trailers
  • MCU Watch Order

TV

  • TV News
  • TV Reviews
  • TV Previews
  • TV Trailers

FRANCHISES

  • Marvel
  • DC
  • Star Wars
  • Goosebumps
  • The Walking Dead
  • TMNT
  • Ghostbusters
  • Star Trek
  • Spawn
  • Christmas
  • Horror

THE PODCAST

  • Episodes
  • Upcoming Episodes
  • Subscribe on Apple
  • Follow on Spotify

More

  • Featured Pull Quotes
  • About Capes & Tights
  • Write for Capes & Tights
  • Contact Us

© 2026 Capes and Tights. All Rights Reserved.

Capes and Tights
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?