What the hell did I just read, in the most wonderful way possible. I knew what to expect from Hailey Piper, I guess I expected the unexpected, and that is what I got. with She Isn’t Herself Tonight. A disturbing, haunting, and grief-filled psychological horror that has me glad Piper continues to write stories that makes me feel uncomfortable.
When Rabbit was ten years old, she was abducted by aliens. Then, it happened again when she was twenty. Now thirty, she’s ready for their next visit. What she isn’t prepared for is her boyfriend callously ending their long-term relationship and ejecting her from their shared home.
As her birthday approaches, the aliens still haven’t arrived. Rabbit descends into a spiral of growing paranoia and bizarre bodily transformations, until soon it seems that even her reflection has a mind of its own. With her only refuge being the chaos of strangers who might not have her best interests at heart, Rabbit worries that her ex’s abandonment not only severed her from his life, but also from her own. Struggling to orient herself within a world growing more topsy-turvy by the day, Rabbit must regain control before her aliens at last return.
Let’s be honest, I should up to this party because it was hosted by the great Hailey Piper, but also because I feel its difficult sometimes to find good, fresh, and disturbing alien abduction horror. Not that I have been actively seeking out this unique sub-genre, but when I read the solicitation, I knew it was something I was eager to dive into.
Not one character in this book felt like the average human being, each one of them had the feeling something was off or that I wanted to deeply dislike them. This made for a reading experience unlike most as I wasn’t really cheering for anyone, maybe outside of our protagonist. This made for an even more unsettling story that got under my skin and disturbed me in ways it’s hard to explain.
This continuing struggle for Rabbit is emotionally intense which added even more depth to the story. She definitely has something going on and it is hard to tell whether she really was abducted or is just dealing with mental illness. Something that brings reality into the mix and makes you question the story as it moves along. She is eagerly awaiting her next experience and unravelling along the way.
As I get to the bottom of this, I realized I am finding it hard to explain my feelings for this book. It wonderful, and uncomfortable, and frightening, and eye-opening, and so much more. All I have to say is read it for yourself.
She Isn’t Herself Tonight is a disturbing psychological horror filled with an emotional intensity and a search for belonging that will stick with you. Author Hailey Piper has a way of getting under your skin in many ways and I am here for every single moment, this story is no different.
She Isn’t Herself Tonight hits bookstores everywhere on October 27, 2027 from Saga Press. The audiobook, narrated by Jenn Lee, is available via Libro.fm!


