By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Capes and Tights
  • Comics

    COMICS

    • Comic News
    • Comic Reviews
    • Comic Previews

    FEATURED PUBLISHERS

    • Marvel Comics
    • DC Comics
    • Image Comics
    • IDW Publishing
    • Dark Horse Comics
    • BOOM! Studios
    • Mad Cave Studios

    THE LATEST IN COMICS

    14 Fabulous Comics by Declan Shalvey You Should Read
    14 Fabulous Comics by Declan Shalvey You Should Read
    FEATURED 4: A Quiet Place: Rising Tides #1, Egg Hunt #1, and November 18 Comics
    FEATURED 4: A Quiet Place: Rising Tides #1, Egg Hunt #1, and November 18 Comics
    Egg Hunt #1
    Egg Hunt #1: An Egg-cellent Start to a Strange New Sci-Fi Horror Series
    FEATURED 4: I Saw Spawn #1, Masterminds TP, and November 11 Comics
    FEATURED 4: I Saw Spawn #1, Masterminds TP, and November 11 Comics

    LATEST COMIC PODCAST

    Jackson Lanzing | Collin Kelly

    #303: Jackson Lanzing & Collin Kelly – Star Trek: The Last Starship, You’ll Never Leave This Place Alive

  • Books

    BOOKS

    • Book News
    • Book Reviews
    • Stephen King

    FEATURED PUBLISHERS

    • Shortwave Publishing
    • Tor Nightfire
    • Saga Press
    • CLASH Books
    • Flatiron Books
    • Blackstone Publishing
    • Poisoned Pen Press

    THE LATEST IN BOOKS

    The One We Buried
    The One We Buried: Some Secrets Are Too Dark to Stay Buried
    The Secret Lives of Zombie Wives
    The Secret Lives of Zombie Wives: A Delightfully Twisted Take on the Undead
    Harry, A History
    Harry, A History (Updated Edition): The Magic Was Always in the Fans
    Ravenous
    Ravenous: Nature Bites Back

    LATEST BOOKS PODCAST

    Alice Openshaw

    #307: Alice Openshaw – On The Killer’s Trail

  • TV

    TV

    • TV News
    • TV Reviews
    • TV Previews
    • TV Trailers

    THE LATEST IN TV

    The Dunder Mifflin Employee Manual
    The Dunder Mifflin Employee Manual: An Ingenious New Way to Revisit The Office
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    I Am the Night
    I Am the Night: Shining the Bat-Signal on an Animated Classic

    LATEST TV PODCAST

    The Lawrence Brothers

    #302: The Lawrence Brothers – The Lawrence Brothers: Detective Agency

  • Movies

    MOVIES

    • Movie News
    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie Previews
    • Movie Trailers
    • Marvel Cinematic Universe
    • MCU Watch Order

    THE LATEST IN MOVIES

    Blumhouse Brings Blockbuster Film Franchises To IDW Publishing's Hit Horror Imprint IDW Dark
    Blumhouse Brings Blockbuster Film Franchises To IDW Publishing’s Hit Horror Imprint IDW Dark
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    13 Magical TV Shows and Movies Starring The Lawrence Brothers You Should Watch
    16 Magical Movies by Kevin Smith You Should Watch
    16 Magical Movies by Kevin Smith You Should Watch

    LATEST MOVIES PODCAST

    The Lawrence Brothers

    #302: The Lawrence Brothers – The Lawrence Brothers: Detective Agency

  • The Podcast

    THE PODCAST

    • Episodes
    • Podcast Schedule
    • Submit to Be a Guest

    SUBSCRIBE

    • Apple
    • Spotify
    • YouTube
    • Amazon
    • Pocket Casts

    RECENT EPISODES

    Alice Openshaw
    #307: Alice Openshaw – On The Killer’s Trail
    Jonathan Edward Durham
    #306: Jonathan Edward Durham – Winterset Hollow
    Casper
    #305: Casper Movie Review
    Kevin Johnson
    #304: Kevin Johnson – ‘Twas the Night

    UPCOMING EPISODES

    Declan Shalvey
    November 18, 2026
    The Nightmare Before Christmas
    December 2, 2026
    Chris Ryall
    November 25, 2026
    Joe Harris
    December 9, 2026
  • Publishers

    COMIC PUBLISHERS

    BOOK PUBLISHERS

    Marvel Comics
    BOOM Studios
    Dynamite
    Image Comics
    DC Comics
    Dark Horse
    IDW
    Mad Cave
    AWA Studios
    DSTLRY
    Ignition Press
    Oni Press
    Blackstone Publishing
    Flatiron Books
    Saga Press
    Clash Books
    Poisoned Pen Press
    Shortwave Publishing
    Crooked Lane Books
  • Franchises

    Franchises

    Marvel Comics
    Goosebumps
    DC Comics
    Ghostbusters
    Star Wars
    Spawn
    Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles | TMNT
    Star Trek
    The Walking Dead
    Horror
Reading: The One We Buried: Some Secrets Are Too Dark to Stay Buried
Share
Capes and Tights
  • Comics
  • Books
  • Movies
  • TV
  • The Podcast

THE PODCAST

  • Episodes
  • Podcast Schedule
  • Submit to Be a Guest
  • Subscribe on Apple
  • Follow on Spotify
  • Subscribe on YouTube

COMICS

  • Comic News
  • Comic Reviews
  • Comic Previews

TV

  • TV News
  • TV Reviews
  • TV Previews
  • TV Trailers

MOVIES

  • Movie News
  • Movie Reviews
  • Movie Previews
  • Movie Trailers

BOOKS

  • Book News
  • Book Reviews
Books

The One We Buried: Some Secrets Are Too Dark to Stay Buried

By
Justin Soderberg
Published: November 16, 2026
19 Views
Share
5 Min Read
The One We Buried
SHARE
The One We Buried
3.5
Review Overview

There’s something about a group of friends sharing a dark secret that can make for a creepy, eerie, and thrilling story. Toss in an atmospheric setting, a few strange rituals, and a growing sense that something isn’t quite right and you’ve got The One We Buried by Kate Alice Marshall. A slow-burning mystery that takes its time building tension before revealing just how deep some secrets can go.

The One We BuriedThirteen years ago, Nic, Alanna, Talia, and Jess were shipped off to Sanctuary Springs, a remote retreat among hills bubbling with hot springs. There, Dr. Elizabeth Sheffield—along with her enigmatic daughter Rachel—ran an experimental program for gifted but troubled girls. At the end of the program, she promised, these young women with their wasted potential would be completely reborn.

Three months later, the girls did emerge changed. They went on to be extremely successful. And none have ever revealed what really happened that summer in the hills.

When Nic is attacked and her fiancé killed, she retreats once more to Sanctuary Springs, where Talia has built a wellness retreat in the renovated facility, intending to bring a watered-down version of their “rebirth” to the masses. The group begins to flirt with old rites and rituals, but when Nic becomes convinced that her fiancé’s murder is connected to what happened all those years ago, old tensions rise and long-buried secrets begin to resurface. As Nic confronts the truth of what happened that summer, she must decide whether to embrace the circle they created—or unravel it for good.

Over the years Marshall has become a nearly must-read for me in the world of mystery and thrillers. So, it was no surprise I was going to be game for The One We Buried. While not my favorite of Marshall’s stories, the growing tension and unease was felt throughout the book. What starts out as a slow-paced and creeping story turns out to be a tale filled with mystery and surprise.

The One We Buried is an atmospheric tale, where the setting really plays a huge role both in the past and present. However, it’s the characters themselves that really drives this story forward. Marshall does a fantastic job taking stories from these characters past and modernizing them, bringing them to the present. There is an incredible weight that has to be felt by someone who has to carry an event that they cannot talk about for over 13 years. What pressure that puts on you to even attempt at a somewhat normal life has to be enormous. This is almost physically felt when reading this book.

The slower start to The One We Buried had me pushing myself forward, as I knew the story would payoff in the end. However, it was a more difficult of Marshall’s books as a whole. Much more strange than any previous tale, which is something I usually grasp onto, but this time it took me a minute. This is likely comes down to personal preference and what keeps my attention, but as I said, it definitely paid off in the end.

The One We Buried is an atmospheric slow-burning thriller filled with unsettling secrets. Kate Alice Marshall brings some stranger elements to the table, delivering on a mystery where the past never stays buried for long.

The One We Buried hits bookstores everywhere on January 26, 2027 from Flatiron Books / Pine & Cedar. The audiobook is available via Libro.fm!

NOTE: We received an advance copy of The One We Buried from the publisher. Opinions are our own.

The One We Buried
Review Overview
3.5
Overall 3.5 out of 5
- Advertisement -
Share This Article
Facebook Threads Email Copy Link Print
ByJustin Soderberg
Follow:
Born and raised in New England, Justin Soderberg currently resides in Orrington, Maine. Soderberg started his career in media covering the UMass Lowell River Hawks, Lowell Spinners, Hockey East, PGA, Boston Bruins, MMA/UFC, and other sports. Now, Soderberg's main goal is to bring you the best possible pop culture coverage with all his effort.
Previous Article 14 Fabulous Comics by Declan Shalvey You Should Read 14 Fabulous Comics by Declan Shalvey You Should Read

LATEST IN BOOKS

The Secret Lives of Zombie Wives

The Secret Lives of Zombie Wives: A Delightfully Twisted Take on the Undead

Justin Soderberg
November 13, 2026
Harry, A History

Harry, A History (Updated Edition): The Magic Was Always in the Fans

Justin Soderberg
November 12, 2026
Ravenous

Ravenous: Nature Bites Back

Justin Soderberg
November 12, 2026
- Advertisement -

LATEST BOOK PODCAST

Alice Openshaw

#307: Alice Openshaw – On The Killer’s Trail

- Advertisement -

BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE

FEATURED 4: Archie in Hell #1, Spider-Woman #1, and November 4 Comics
Comics

FEATURED 4: Archie in Hell #1, Spider-Woman #1, and November 4 Comics

Ravenous
Books

Ravenous: Nature Bites Back

Egg Hunt #1
Mad Cave Studios

Egg Hunt #1: An Egg-cellent Start to a Strange New Sci-Fi Horror Series

Deadly Shore
Books

Deadly Shore: Secrets Run Deep on the Maine Coast

Swamp Thing is Killing the Children #1
BOOM! Studios

Swamp Thing is Killing the Children #1: Proof Some Worlds Were Meant to Collide

The Sixth Faction
Book Reviews

The Sixth Faction: Veronica Roth Finds a New Path Through Divergent

Capes and Tights

COMICS

  • Comic News
  • Comic Reviews
  • Comic Previews
  • Marvel Comics
  • DC Comics
  • Image Comics
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • IDW Publishing
  • BOOM! Studios
  • Mad Cave Studios
  • Ignition Press

BOOKS

  • Book News
  • Book Reviews
  • Anna Rose Reads
  • Shortwave Publishing
  • Tor Nightfire
  • Saga Press
  • CLASH Books
  • Flatiron Books
  • Blackstone Publishing
  • Poisoned Pen Press
  • Stephen King

Movies

  • Movie News
  • Movie Reviews
  • Movie Previews
  • Movie Trailers
  • MCU Watch Order

TV

  • TV News
  • TV Reviews
  • TV Previews
  • TV Trailers

FRANCHISES

  • Marvel
  • DC
  • Star Wars
  • Goosebumps
  • The Walking Dead
  • TMNT
  • Ghostbusters
  • Star Trek
  • Spawn
  • Christmas
  • Horror

THE PODCAST

  • Episodes
  • Upcoming Episodes
  • Subscribe on Apple
  • Follow on Spotify

More

  • Featured Pull Quotes
  • About Capes & Tights
  • Write for Capes & Tights
  • Contact Us

© 2026 Capes and Tights. All Rights Reserved.

Capes and Tights
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?