There’s something about a group of friends sharing a dark secret that can make for a creepy, eerie, and thrilling story. Toss in an atmospheric setting, a few strange rituals, and a growing sense that something isn’t quite right and you’ve got The One We Buried by Kate Alice Marshall. A slow-burning mystery that takes its time building tension before revealing just how deep some secrets can go.
Thirteen years ago, Nic, Alanna, Talia, and Jess were shipped off to Sanctuary Springs, a remote retreat among hills bubbling with hot springs. There, Dr. Elizabeth Sheffield—along with her enigmatic daughter Rachel—ran an experimental program for gifted but troubled girls. At the end of the program, she promised, these young women with their wasted potential would be completely reborn.
Three months later, the girls did emerge changed. They went on to be extremely successful. And none have ever revealed what really happened that summer in the hills.
When Nic is attacked and her fiancé killed, she retreats once more to Sanctuary Springs, where Talia has built a wellness retreat in the renovated facility, intending to bring a watered-down version of their “rebirth” to the masses. The group begins to flirt with old rites and rituals, but when Nic becomes convinced that her fiancé’s murder is connected to what happened all those years ago, old tensions rise and long-buried secrets begin to resurface. As Nic confronts the truth of what happened that summer, she must decide whether to embrace the circle they created—or unravel it for good.
Over the years Marshall has become a nearly must-read for me in the world of mystery and thrillers. So, it was no surprise I was going to be game for The One We Buried. While not my favorite of Marshall’s stories, the growing tension and unease was felt throughout the book. What starts out as a slow-paced and creeping story turns out to be a tale filled with mystery and surprise.
The One We Buried is an atmospheric tale, where the setting really plays a huge role both in the past and present. However, it’s the characters themselves that really drives this story forward. Marshall does a fantastic job taking stories from these characters past and modernizing them, bringing them to the present. There is an incredible weight that has to be felt by someone who has to carry an event that they cannot talk about for over 13 years. What pressure that puts on you to even attempt at a somewhat normal life has to be enormous. This is almost physically felt when reading this book.
The slower start to The One We Buried had me pushing myself forward, as I knew the story would payoff in the end. However, it was a more difficult of Marshall’s books as a whole. Much more strange than any previous tale, which is something I usually grasp onto, but this time it took me a minute. This is likely comes down to personal preference and what keeps my attention, but as I said, it definitely paid off in the end.
The One We Buried is an atmospheric slow-burning thriller filled with unsettling secrets. Kate Alice Marshall brings some stranger elements to the table, delivering on a mystery where the past never stays buried for long.
The One We Buried hits bookstores everywhere on January 26, 2027 from Flatiron Books / Pine & Cedar. The audiobook is available via Libro.fm!


