There is no doubt that Clay McLeod Chapman has become a must-read horror author, not just for me, but I would imagine for a great deal of people. His latest novel, Mr. Lonelyhearts, only increased his must-readability with a uniquely weird, unhinged, and creepy tale.
When Jenn first sees Mr. Lonelyhearts, he’s just a CPR dummy in her 7th grade health class. She and her best friends―the Cöven―smuggle him to a sleepover and pour their adolescent fantasies into his open, willing vessel. Then they grow up, get real boyfriends, and forget about him. But he never forgot about them. And now, decades later, after a traumatic break-up leaves Jenn shattered, Mr. Lonelyhearts reappears in her life to pick up the pieces.
But once Jenn begins to suspect that there’s something very wrong about her Mr. Right, it might be too late. Will she survive this situationship, or does Mr. Lonelyhearts have darker plans for them?
Wow, this one was interesting, but also so much fun to read. Chapman really dives deep into the idea of loneliness as a terrifying thing, maybe the most terrifying thing in a book that features gruesome death and other horrors. A universal feeling, Chapman really taps into the feeling in such a deep and wild way, almost forcing us to feel the loneliness in step with our main character Jenn making the emotion horror just as scary as the physical horror taking place. This made for such an uncomfortable reading experience, but an experience that you almost wish upon yourself in an unexplainable way.
At first Jenn seems to have things handled, but things start to quickly unravel and goes into a very dark place. She has many flaws, but let’s be honest don’t we all, but after what she has been through we have to understand. With all this, many of us would be emotionally drained and depressed which would lead to some unhinged thoughts. What this does is make her almost unreliable which gives the reader more work to find out what to trust. There are times where I wanted to believe what was going on was only in her head, but then she has real life conversations with her friends and mother and I end up not knowing what to believe. An unsettling feeling as a reader, that is for sure.
Only someone such as Chapman would use a CPR dummy as the antagonist in a horror story. But here is the thing, it was hard to figure out wether or not said CPR dummy is truly the problem or are we so far in Jenn’s head that we are being manipulating alongside her to think he might be stalking her or even killing others. This confusion is what made this story unsettling. It’s a wild and unhinged experience Chapman sends us on where I really could understand it fully, but is what made turning the page so worth it.
Chapman not only tells a terrifying tale with Mr. Lonelyhearts, but one where he takes the slasher and turns in on its head creating a fresh new take on the genre. He deliberately creates discomfort through uncertainty and emotion that had me squirming in my seat, but also eagerly awaiting the next page. The result: an expertly controlled sense of chaos.
Mr. Lonelyhearts is an unhinged, unsettling, and incredibly unique slasher where you don’t know what is truly making you scared. Clay McLeod Chapman delivers a fantastic tale, blending some extreme, grotesque horror with relatable human emotions. Mr. Lonelyhearts made me uncomfortable, but in such an amazing way. Also, NEVER forget your tote bag.
Mr. Lonelyhearts hits bookstores everywhere on March 23, 2027 from Tor Nightfire. The audiobook, narrated by Jenn Lee, is available via Libro.fm!


